Main content

Is impartiality a myth?

William Crawley chairs a live debate examining the moral issues behind one of the week's news stories. With Giles Fraser, Mona Siddiqui, Inaya Folarin-Iman and Ash Sarkar.

The 主播大秀 has published new guidance on how its big name presenters can use social media. Those working in news and current affairs are still bound by strict rules on impartiality, which the 主播大秀 sees as being fundamental to its reputation, values and the trust of its audiences. But the presenters of other programmes are free to express their political views, as long as they don鈥檛 鈥渆ndorse or attack a political party."

While impartiality means not favouring one side over another, news broadcasters are subject to a subtler version of it: 鈥渄ue impartiality鈥. That means different perspectives don鈥檛 necessarily have to be given equal weight. But which perspectives and how much weight? That鈥檚 a matter of judgment.

The changing media landscape has brought new challenges to the principle of impartiality. The media regulator Ofcom has recently investigated GB News. Among their alleged breaches of impartiality was an item in which the Conservative Chancellor was interviewed by two other Conservative MPs.

The spiritual heirs of Lord Reith believe that media impartiality is a moral good and a central pillar of democracy in an age of populism and polarisation. Sceptics suggest that the pursuit of impartiality can create problems of its own, putting ignorance and expertise on an equal footing.

Beyond broadcasting, how much should we as individuals strive for impartiality? Is it possible to look at historical events through an objective lens? While psychology tells us we all have cognitive biases, psychologists disagree about how much they can be corrected. Is it possible to be truly impartial about ourselves and others?

Producer: Dan Tierney

Available now

57 minutes

Last on

Sun 8 Oct 2023 23:00

Broadcasts

  • Wed 4 Oct 2023 20:00
  • Sun 8 Oct 2023 23:00

The Evidence Toolkit

The Evidence Toolkit

Check out the claims made in news stories with this interactive tool.

Podcast