Ö÷²¥´óÐã

Ö÷²¥´óÐã BLOGS - John Beattie
« Previous | Main | Next »

Can the Commonwealth brand be salvaged?

Post categories:

John Beattie | 18:42 UK time, Sunday, 3 October 2010

Commonwealth 2010 has damaged the Games "brand". The damage wasn't solely inflicted by India and its inability to finish projects in time, nor by corrupt politicians - my you surprise me - no, the brand has been damaged by athletes who were scared to come here or didn't think it was important enough and, as I said in the last blog, the "civilised" West's toffee-nosed look down at the Indian way.

Everyone was assured that if the village wasn't ready then top hotels would be paid for.

As there is extra pressure on we Scots to make out that the Games remain every bit as important as before, but key athletes told us that, actually, they don't think that's the case.

Therefore they can't be. Some top athletes have snubbed India and the Commonwealth concept.

The huge job now is to rebuild this brand for Glasgow 2014. It is, to some extent, up to my little country to persuade the greats of the world stage that the event is something you have to attend.

Scotland flag bearer Ross Edgar leads the team at the Commonwealth Games opening ceremony

Scottish flag-bearer Ross Edgar leads the team at the Commonwealth Games opening ceremony

I'm just back in the hotel after watching the opening ceremony.

I am 52-years-old now and way past the halfway point in my life. The result is that I get emotional at these things because I know that the people around me will see more of them than I will now, and so I concentrate and remember what I am watching and how I feel.

In 1995, I burst into tears when the , right in front of me, wearing a Springbok jersey at the rugby World Cup final in Johannesburg. It was the rebirth of South Africa, and Johannesburg was the murder capital of the world.

Did the rugby players call off? No.

Johannesburg is still the murder capital of the world, tourists get robbed all the time, but did football teams snub the football World Cup there this summer? No.

The opening ceremony of the in Shanghai three years ago was stunning. They built a Great Wall made of humans and then even more humans climbed it.

People miss the point of opening ceremonies. They appear to be a waste of money.

But I always read the same, almost naïve but central message, in everyone one of them, which is: "Please come to our country, please accept us, we want to be your friends."

That's what we Scots will say too.

Governments can be truly terrible, but most people are, actually, fantastic.

Opening ceremonies feel like the most un-cool kid in class asking to be accepted. They lay bare their soul.

And in this case India, and the Commonwealth Games, were rejected by some who thought that neither was cool enough.

In my head it started with , and Usain Bolt, Phillips Idowu and Asafa Powell, and swimmer Stephanie Rice. It's a long list.

Bolt's agent was quoted as saying it wasn't "on his schedule" - which means he didn't think it was important enough.

And that was damaging. I looked at the Jamaican team walking past without Bolt and thought - they haven't brought their best team. Neither have England or, for that matter, Scotland.

I don't quite understand those who accept public money to train and then choose not to come, and well done to those who are here.

Scotland has a job to win medals, and, despite every public utterance I read or hear, the added task of re-burnishing a brand in the process.

Please tell me I'm wrong...

Comments

  • Comment number 1.

    little bit disappointed, no mention of how the Opening ceremony was ?
    BTW for what its worth I think it was the best ever.

  • Comment number 2.

    nice article, enjoyed reading it. your blog is refreshing to read.

  • Comment number 3.

    John, loved reading your article. How I agree with every word you wrote. I feel embarrassed that our athletes have pulled out. I feel they are missing out on one of great competitions.

  • Comment number 4.

    Brand...agent... sounds like as if we are buying some supermarket product...

  • Comment number 5.

    Very good blog John. I think you hit the nail on the head. These athletes who are now 'concentrating' on bigger events will just end up not qualifying for these 'big' events.

  • Comment number 6.

    John, you have pretty much summed up the feeling of a nation, or for that matter any nation.

    Your aptly written statement "Please come to our country, please accept us, we want to be your friends." has a lot of depth, only if people really understand it. I truly think these athletes have missed something great, They have missed the chance to be part of a spectacle that is India. Let me tell one and all - in years to come India will NOT forget those who came and those who DIDN'T. It wasn't for no reason when someone said life comes a full circle and for those who have disregarded true Indian hospitality will wish they had not done this.

    For India and especially the young Indians who have felt pain (because of the media or the mismanagement or the corruption), very well done there for the opening ceremony. The games will also be a great success. Rise and shine the future is yours. India was never known for these bureaucrats, its the common citizen (rich or poor) of the nation that makes India what she is.

  • Comment number 7.

    Some people are easily impressed. Frankly, I find all these Opening Ceremonies childish as each nation tries to better another through a spectacle. I hope come the 2012 Olympics, the Opening Ceremony will be unpretentious & full of things which will go wrong in a funny way, thus highlighting Britain's strength: its eccentricity!
    Aman/Mahatma? Do you read me?

  • Comment number 8.

    Good one, John. Thoughtfully well written! I agree with the premise; that the brand is tarnished and diminished by those who withdrew.
    Unless there's overwhelming pressure by the competing nations to force their athletes to participate, and as you point out there is leverage via funding, then we can expect more of this in Glasgow. Pity!

  • Comment number 9.

    john!
    You seem quite mesmerized and awestruck from the intense visual and colourful experience that you just witnessed!
    wish I were there too!

    Scotland will be good too in 2014!

    Hail commonwealth!

  • Comment number 10.

    At every Commonwealth Games I can remember, which is many, there is talk of them being devalued by the non-appearance of certain athletes but nobody remembers this when you look at the history records. It is the winners who are remembered and those who didn't go will have the regrets.

    What I cannot understand is for those who are in Delhi, deciding not to attend the opening ceremony. Watching and enjoying the ceremony on television it would appear not many Scottish athletes were there and this seems confirmed by the photograph above. Certainly not in comparison with countries sending similar sized teams to the games like New Zealand or indeed Wales with a smaller team. Was this a reaction to the hissy-fit the Scottish team management seem to take regarding the arrangements for the opening ceremony? Someone should remind them it's the "Friendly Games" as they're getting a reputation.

    Jamie Murray writing on the Ö÷²¥´óÐã website yesterday was extolling the virtues of the Opening Ceremony and his determination to attend even though scheduled to play on Monday. That didn't happen, in fact according to his twitter he didn't even watch the ceremony on tv, preferring the Ryder Cup.

    I wonder if they can get a refund on all those kilts which weren't required.

  • Comment number 11.

    Perhaps John before criticising those who have withdrawn you should educate yourself as to why they have withdrawn rather than just rolling out a soundbite about their funding.

    The fact is our top stars are funded to perform at Olympics & World Champs and not the Commonwealth Games so it's irrelevant. That's why Chris Hoy & our other top cyclists have withdrawn as they have to concentrate on the European Champs which are a qualification event for London 2012. The top Gymnasts are also not here because the Gymnastics world champs are just a week after the Delhi Games & again it's acting as a qualification event for the Olympics.

    The top athletes who have withdrawn like Jessica Ennis & Usain Bolt have done so because of the timing of the event as it will eat into their training times. Those two will be under enormous pressure in London - in Jessica's case as the best chance of a home Olympic Gold medallist in track & Field and in Bolt's case to set world records every time he steps out. The armchair critics would be the first to criticise if they under achieve in London so let's just back off.

  • Comment number 12.

    Good article John. I will note down the names of all athletes who pulled out and follow their performances in world championships and London 2012. I am sure that from The games in Delhi new champions will be born and will have enough motivation to do well in London 2012.

  • Comment number 13.

    Tiger Rose,if you look at the photo above you will see the flag bearer is Ross Edgar who I believe is one of our top cyclists and obviously has not withdrawn, anyway London 2012 is 2 years away, plenty of time to qualify.
    I think John has a valid point about credibility especially for Scottish athletes, taking into account Glasgow 2014, actions speak louder than words.
    Well done to ALL athletes and officials in Delhi, I'm sure it will be amazing.

  • Comment number 14.

    Why don't the governing bodies that provide money for these athletes stipulate the tournaments that they 'MUST' attend to get their money. Only an independant doctor should allow non attendance.

  • Comment number 15.

    I watched the opening ceremony and despite it being colourful it looks like the wind has been taken out of it. like an average carnival with street performers and so so choregraphy it does not have any real emotion or technical brilliance like we saw at the Olympics.

  • Comment number 16.

    Just woken up...

    Eileen Dover - athletes competing on the first or second days are not allowed to take part in the opening ceremony as is custom as it is thought it hinders their performances, thus no David Carry etc

    Off for breakfast = commentating at the pool all day, and will come back here in an hour

  • Comment number 17.

    "athletes competing on the first or second days are not allowed to take part in the opening ceremony as is custom as it is thought it hinders their performances, thus no David Carry etc"

    Good morning John.

    "Not allowed" sounds draconian but probably in keeping with the Team Scotland regime. This law obviously doesn't apply to other countries as David Davies not only attended the opening ceremony but was the Welsh flag bearer and I've just watch him beat the aforementioned David Carry in their heat of the 400m freestyle.

    Perhaps a rethink is required as there may be benefits from attending the ceremony in absorbing the atmosphere of the games which certainly seems to be lacking at the pool.

  • Comment number 18.

    Good breakfast - roti, eggs, bacon, porridge, fruit, coffee - not in that order

    Ian Cheese - I take your point entirely. I have a large dose of cynicism in me, but when I look around at the faces of the people who have bought tickets to these things they really do think their country is extending the hand of friendship. There isn't much wrong with a world where people are asking to be accepted by the privileged.

    Michael - The top athletes like Chris Hoy are on Olympic programme money which is to do with team GB. In theory Chris is not paid to compete at the Commonwealths. To me it's all margins, if he'd really wanted to he could have but the Europeans, which clash, are more important.

    Tiger Rose - it was your point I was stating there, but it does all reflect the perceived status of the Commonwealths. I kept looking at the Jamaican team thinking - it's not their top team. The thing about any event is that, in some way, it must clash with another event, or the training for another event, or the build up to another event, or the off season to another event, or........you get the picture. Ultimately the athletes concerned made a choice as to what was more important, the build up to another event or the Commonwealth games.

    Baked Beans - Nope, replace brand with concept or event or status or image if you like.

    Eileen Dover - possibly it's convention then, as Willie Wood, for instance, wasn't to take part in the march as he is competing on day one.

    Oh, and Steve Cram says that Steve Ovett and Seb Coe didn't go to the 1978 Commonwealths, so a young Steve Cram went instead,

  • Comment number 19.

    cracking Article, the commonwealth games should always be a major event in any sportsmans life!

  • Comment number 20.

    ultimate opening in our country created History in Common Wealth games & its unbelievable - Pround be an Indian - Jai Hind.

  • Comment number 21.

    20. At 09:18am on 04 Oct 2010, vipan dhand wrote:
    ultimate opening in our country created History in Common Wealth games & its unbelievable - Pround be an Indian - Jai Hind.

    I totally agree, India has every right to be proud. The opening ceremony was spectacular and I only hope when the games come to Scotland, we can put on a matching display.
    I watched the opening Bowls Triples match this morning between India and Australia. The Indians acquitted themselves very well and it was only their inexperience that cost them the game. They will improve as the games go on.

  • Comment number 22.

    This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

  • Comment number 23.

    ian cheese, you sound like a 'frog in a well', narrow and limited in outlook and reach. Jump from one side to other and claim that you know it all and that is all that exists. Its just that you are ignorant mate and honestly, you are making fool of yourself.

  • Comment number 24.

    23. At 2:09pm on 04 Oct 2010, Ravi wrote:
    --------
    Ravi,
    Oh my goodness gracious me! Where are you coming from?

    You can only resort to insults. That reflects an uneducated & unrefined mind. Where are your arguments before your conclusions i.e. I am a 'frog in a well', narrow & limited in outlook & reach, jumping from one side to other, etc. To begin with, you have not addressed what I said! eg. the monkeys having a role, after all Hanuman is one of the Monkey gods! What really defines the true India, etc. You do not represent the majority of Indians because they will heartily agree with what I say.

  • Comment number 25.

    18. At 06:08am on 04 Oct 2010, John Beattie - Ö÷²¥´óÐã Sport wrote:

    ...There isn't much wrong with a world where people are asking to be accepted by the privileged.
    -------------
    Aye, but it shouldn't be the case that the privileged have no legitimate say because they are privileged.
    In any case, I am only a humble Bus driver.


  • Comment number 26.

    Ian Cheese, Where are you coming from mate? and What do you know about India? Just that it was a British Colony as that is what you were taught? And now you find it difficult to digest that soon your former colony will out-pace you? I am resorting to insult? you might want to read your comments again. At least I am not trying to run-down a whole country and belittle their efforts and achievements.

    You can do better with your 'Educated and refined' mind than that.

  • Comment number 27.

    Ian Cheese - I am only a former rugby player. To have released the monkeys would have been fun.

    Can anybody help me here - how do you get around Delhi quickly?

    :-)

    JB

  • Comment number 28.

    26. At 3:32pm on 04 Oct 2010, Ravi wrote:
    ... at least I am not trying to run-down a whole country and belittle their efforts and achievements.
    -----------
    My dear Ravi,

    You got the wrong end of the stick mate!
    How was I trying to run down a whole country & belittle their efforts & achievements?
    I simply said that some humour & humanity in the proceedings would have endeared the rest of the world to India! I wished the Pandas could have taken Central stage in China during the Olympics in 2008. I think the Monkeys would have been wonderful for India, specially as they have been rounded up & caged. Or would you have preferred the Cows or the Cobras-some defining image of India! After all, the Indians regard the Monkeys & Cows as sacred, I don't know about Cobras, you have to enlighten me here. Please, don't regard this as an insult because no one does except you & your ilk.

    I am only a Bus driver, was hoping that you had a more refined & educated mind.

  • Comment number 29.

    27. At 3:33pm on 04 Oct 2010, John Beattie - Ö÷²¥´óÐã Sport wrote:
    Ian Cheese - I am only a former rugby player. To have released the monkeys would have been fun.

    -------------

    Listen 'ere, I'm not scared of yer jus 'cos you are a rugby player, bigger than I am! You jocks ain't succeedin at rugby either!
    Don't fink you can 'ave 'andled those monkeys if they 'ave been let loose!

  • Comment number 30.

    This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

  • Comment number 31.

    Ian cheese: You can only resort to insults. That reflects an uneducated & unrefined mind. Where are your arguments before your conclusions i.e. I am a 'frog in a well', narrow & limited in outlook & reach, jumping from one side to other, etc. To begin with, you have not addressed what I said! eg. the monkeys having a role, after all Hanuman is one of the Monkey gods! What really defines the true India, etc. You do not represent the majority of Indians because they will heartily agree with what I say.
    -------------------
    Ian please dont mind at Ravi's reply. I think he just interpreted you in a different sense altogether and not in the lighter and a more humane animal friendly manner. I do understand where you're coming from and fully support your views. I myself found those langurs guarding the village boundary really cute and it only shows to what length the people of this country are going to ensure people in the village are happy and fine.
    ----------------
    Now on a different note, Ive been following the blogs ,and Ö÷²¥´óÐã in general, pretty closely and I have to admit that Ö÷²¥´óÐã is a little indifferent towards India. We all know and admit the opening ceremony was truely great and in fact greater because the last few weeks had set wrong precedents for the entire CWG preparations and I wonder how badly the morale of the thousands of volunteers must have got affected. Despite all those odds, they still managed to come out with such a grand and an almost perfect opening ceremony is really commendable. I as a citizen was hiding in shame and in utter disgust over the last few weeks revelations about India's unpreparedness. Ö÷²¥´óÐã and also some 'well educated western journalists' always try their best to portray India in a manner which is low and objectionable to any Indian as it would be to any patriotic national anywhere in the world. But I want to highlight one fact and that is Ö÷²¥´óÐã always concentrates on the bad part first or even if they show the good part , they end it up with the bad part every single time. e.g. yesterday, the Ö÷²¥´óÐã reporter, despite hailing the ceremony, pointed out and played video of a group in which 2 girls fell down as they could not balance properly because of their heavy attire.
    But despite all this, what I like the best is that a common 'Non Indian' realises this fact and is more far reasonable in its thinking. My appeal to Ö÷²¥´óÐã and the rest (incl. Indian media sometimes), please dont be judgemental, you've got to look at the bigger picture and come out of this stereotypical mindset about India being a third world country. Let me tell you, India is rising and trying its best, albeit all the myriad issues like corruption, poverty, energy/water crisis etc, to come out of the closet. Please let it rise, dont shame it, guide it if you want to.

    I'm confident that the games will finish off well without any major issues and after that we have tasks to sort out and sure we will fight each and everybody who almost collapsed the entire CWG and the country's image.

  • Comment number 32.

    31. At 7:15pm on 04 Oct 2010, Varun wrote:
    ---------
    Dear Varun,

    Thank you kindly for your contribution.
    I don't think anyone is against India.
    1. The officials responsible for not getting things shipshape & on time for the CWG should have come clean immediately & apologised, & not offered excuses. That would have neutralised the criticisms immediately. One cannot defend the indefensible. We are all fallible, some more so than others, the point is to make amends, move on & try to perform better;
    2. The major issue for many people is the poor hygiene standards in India, this certainly needs major improvements;
    3. The gods, animals & traditions of India eg. snake charming are its most endearing qualities.

  • Comment number 33.

    Dear John,

    I would imagine that you are better off using an auto rickshaw, or even better, a hired taxi for a day (they are quite cheap compared to the UK), as it would be the most convenient and quick method of moving about in Delhi. Don't try driving yourself though :-).
    Also, the metro trains are very comfortable, but I am not sure they still have all the stations operational to get you where you want to go. Good Luck!!

  • Comment number 34.

    ''England women's hockey coach Danny Kerry slammed Commonwealth Games organisers after his team were forced to play in baking and 'dangerous' 40-degree temperatures''

    Give up guys what do you expect when you got play in different country. I hope they might not ask for indoor hockey stadium with air conditioning.
    Haaaaaaaaaaaa Bloody whimps

Ìý

Ö÷²¥´óÐã iD

Ö÷²¥´óÐã navigation

Ö÷²¥´óÐã © 2014 The Ö÷²¥´óÐã is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.