主播大秀

bbc.co.uk Navigation

Bryn Palmer

Best and worst of RWC so far (56)

Paris - With all 20 teams in this World Cup having played two matches each 鈥 before kick-off 鈥榬ound three鈥 on Wednesday 鈥 how about some 鈥榟alfway through the pool stages鈥 awards?

Not the snappiest of titles I鈥檒l admit, but we鈥檒l revisit them at the end of the group stages, and again at the end of the tournament.

Do let me know who I鈥檝e missed out, which ones I鈥檝e got wrong, and your own nominations for further awards.

Best individual performance: Fourie du Preez ()

England coach Brian Ashton had warned us the Springboks possessed 鈥渙ne of the most intelligent scrum-halves in world rugby鈥 beforehand. Unfortunately, it didn鈥檛 appear he had warned his own team. Du Preez stamped his authority all over his side鈥檚 critical pool match with a virtuoso display of tactical kicking, sniping runs, and bullet passes. He started the moves which led to all three Springboks tries, and then gave the scoring pass for each one. If the rest of the world didn鈥檛 already know about him, they do now. The 23-year-old is a star in the making.

Worst individual performance: Brian Lima ()

Plenty of competition here, and not just because it would be unfair to single out one Irishman. David Skrela鈥檚 opening gambit for France against Argentina deserves a mention, as does Shaun Perry鈥檚 nightmare 40 minutes for England against South Africa, after which 鈥 as the jargon goes 鈥 he 鈥榝ailed to reappear for the second half鈥. But as a way to celebrate becoming the first man to play in five World Cups, Samoan legend Brian Lima got it all wrong. Coming on as a replacement, 鈥淭he Chiropractor鈥 sought to justify his moniker with a trademark crunching tackle bordering on the reckless, knocked himself out, conceded a penalty, then departed in a haze three minutes after his entrance.

Best team performance: Georgia ()

To put it into some sort of context, Georgia rocked up at the last World Cup and were hammered 84-6 in their opening game by England, then the best team in the northern hemisphere. This time they pressed Argentina hard before conceding a fourth try only in injury-time. On their second outing, the 17th-ranked nation in the world spent the last few minutes hammering away for a try that would have given them victory over Ireland, the second best team in Europe. If it wasn鈥檛 for a timely intervention by Denis Leamy, leading to a Georgian try disallowed by the video referee, Bordeaux鈥檚 Stade Jacques-Chaban-Delmas would have witnessed the greatest upset in World Cup history. Mention must also go to Argentina for their stunning opening-night win over France.

Worst team performance: England ()

Only four teams in the history of the World Cup had failed to score a point in a game prior to this tournament: Ivory Coast (against Scotland in 1995), Canada (against South Africa, 1995), Spain (against Scotland, 1999) and Namibia (against Australia, 2003). They were all minnows of the game. But we can now add to this inglorious list world champions England, following their execrable 36-0 rout by South Africa. (Romania became the sixth after their 42-0 defeat on Tuesday by Scotland 鈥 who have now 鈥榥illed鈥 three teams in World Cups.) In terms of a rival for England so far, Ireland鈥檚 opening display against Namibia probably runs it closest, although Italy鈥檚 lame capitulation at the hands of New Zealand was also a pitiful effort.

Best individual try: Bryan Habana ()

The Springboks wing wasted no time living up to his reputation as the most dangerous wing in world rugby. When he took a routine pass from Jaques Fourie down the blind side of a ruck, with the score still only 9-7, there appeared little on. But the 24-year-old cut inside two players, stepped out of the tackle of a third whereupon he looked about to stumble, only to recover his balance, rapidly switch direction to confuse three other Samoans and then turn on the gas to burst through a gap, holding off another tackler on the line. As a game-breaking effort, it took some beating. A spectacular long-range effort followed in the second half, plus two more for good measure.

Best team try: Rui Cordeiro ()

The All Blacks opened their World Cup account with 11 tries against Italy, some of them absolute beauties, and stretched their legs further with 16 more against Portugal, ranked 22nd in the world, on their way to the sixth 100-plus points victory in World Cup history. But none of them were celebrated with the unrestrained joy that greeted Portugal鈥檚 only try in the same game. Resuming after the interval 52-3 down, 鈥淥s Lobos鈥 kept New Zealand out for the first seven minutes of the second half. And then, after a series of drives took them to the All Blacks line, the video referee ruled that replacement prop Cordeiro had touched the ball down under a scrum of bodies. It epitomised what the World Cup is all about, regardless of the final scoreline (108-13).

Worst tackle: Jacques Nieuwenhuis ()

It takes something to stop a marauding Sebastien Chabal in his tracks, and Namibia鈥檚 number eight resorted to a swinging arm round the bearded Frenchman鈥檚 throat. Having already been warned by referee Alain Rolland minutes earlier for a similarly dangerous tackle on Vincent Clerc, it wasn鈥檛 the brightest move right in front of the French-speaking Irish whistler, with the first quarter of the match not even complete. Rolland had no hesitation in brandishing a red card to Nieuwenhuis, who no doubt had some making up to do with his 14 team-mates after they spent the next hour desperately trying to stop France running in tries for fun, to little avail.

Best pre-match motivational tactic:

Samoa coach Michael Jones, speaking after his side鈥檚 opening defeat against South Africa, admitted that facing England was the big target for his team now, after the small matter of 鈥済etting past our Polynesian cousins鈥 first. Jones meant no disrespect to Tonga, who had not beaten their Pacific Island neighbours for a decade, but it can't have gone unnoticed. Tonga were already working on the philosophy: 鈥淏elieve and it will probably happen. Don鈥檛 believe and it probably won鈥檛.鈥 Samoa gave every impression of believing they only had to turn up at Montpellier鈥檚 Stade de la Mosson to win. Tonga, led by the magnificently coiffeured Finau Maka, believed otherwise.

Worst pre-match motivational tactic:

A few hours before , full-back Clement Poitrenaud, at the behest of the Tricolores coach Bernard Laporte, read out a letter to the rest of the squad written by 17-year-old French Resistance fighter , composed a few hours before he was killed by the Germans in October 1941. The same letter was read out by French President Nicolas Sarkozy, who has appointed Laporte his Sports Minister after the World Cup, during his election campaign. Many of the players were said to be deeply moved and distressed by the reading. News of the incident leaked out and provoked a storm of indignation in the French media for several days, following a deeply distressing display by the players on their big night.

Bryn Palmer is the 主播大秀 Sport website鈥檚 rugby union editor.


Comments  Post your comment

  • 1.
  • At 04:17 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • Tony Shearer wrote:

Everybody in the England camp comes out with no credit; they have all failed lamentably. None more so than Rob Andrew who even as a player ensured that for years England under-achieved. He shoud be the first to go. His replacement should be Les Cusworth; the Director of Rugby of those over-achievers Argentina; the coach who took Uruguay to the 2003 World Cup. Get on with it We cannot tolerate any more of this.

  • 2.
  • At 04:20 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • CAM wrote:

主播大秀 Nations Side Not Playing Like Complete Mince Award?

Scotland. Two wins, and one clean sheet. Look in great shape to beat Italy and get to a level par quarter-final.

Without all the fuss and kicking and screaming that is currently enveloping Ireland, England and Wales.

  • 3.
  • At 05:24 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • Erik wrote:

The jury's out on Scotland until after they've played the ABs. Then we'll see some kicking and screaming!

  • 4.
  • At 05:27 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • fief wrote:

How about the best place kicker in the tournament so far....Chris Patterson at 100% ?

  • 5.
  • At 05:31 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • Alex wrote:

The way its looking there is a good chance that none of the isles will make it through the group stages...

Wonder what the odds on that would be

  • 6.
  • At 05:38 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • John Hartnell wrote:

I watched France v Namibia on French TV. Immediately after the Jacques Nieuwenhuis tackle on Sebastien Chabal and before any replay, the French commentator said words to the effect, "That could be a yellow card!" He was surprised (and a little delighted I suspect) when a red card ensued.

Having watched the replay, I was of the opinion that the swinging arm didn't actually catch the throat, although M. Chabal went down like he'd been shot, only to make a Lazarus-like resurrection once the red card was flourished. He then set about the remaining Namibians like a man in fine fettle - thus leaving me pondering whether:-

a)Alain Roland's red card has miraculous restorative properties!

b)Le Sauvage dived to con the ref!

  • 7.
  • At 05:46 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • Tall Welshman wrote:

I agree with Erik, there is no way of knowing how well Scotland are doing untill they come up against a half decent team. The crunch game for them has always been the Italy one and i can't see the Italians playing as badly as they did against the AB's again.

  • 8.
  • At 08:28 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • JustDesserts wrote:

The French team underperforms after having a letter from the Resistance read out to them. They then underperform ...

Maybe it's collective guilt? The FFR collaborated with the Vichy government, going as far as to get another sport banned for its own advancement.

The FFR has never apologised for its actions, and it's truly sickening to think that anyone associated with that organisation believes they have a right to take inspiration from resistance fighters.

I can only think that Guy Moquet would have been pleased with the loss.

  • 9.
  • At 08:28 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • henry brittain wrote:

i think andy farrel should be in the worst individual performance for the match against south africa and for every other match he is goin to play in for england (why why why) he played disgracefully his kincking was poor he did it far to often he didnt think, he had poor handling he didnt make many ball runes. Jason robinson on the other hand should be the winner of a best englishmen player event for is amazing performance against south africa before pulling his hamstring and should be rememberd as a rugby legend for england 2nd place should be olly barkly for the match against usa

  • 10.
  • At 08:30 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • Tooks wrote:

Best bosh of the tournament:
Andrew Sheridan on paul emerick in the 48th minute (England vs USA)

  • 11.
  • At 08:31 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • Jack wrote:

What is this rubbish about Scotland being the best home team so far, if you haven't noticed Wales have had a much harder couple of games, Canada, who are better than portugal and romania, and australia the 3rd best team in the world. They have come up with valliant second half performances which has saved them from looking dreadful, and some inspirational performances from Shane Williams and Tom Shanklin alike have DEFINATELY MADE THEM THE BEST HOME NATION SO FAR!

  • 12.
  • At 09:24 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • Cariad wrote:

I'm with you John Hartnell. If (if) Chabal was dazed, it was more likely from the ball inadvertently squashed in his face when he went down than the tackle itself. The Namibian was unlucky. Even though there was only ever going to be one winner, his sending off spoilt the game for me.

  • 13.
  • At 09:26 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • Tinoflyer wrote:

Best home nation has got to be Scotland. They have not lost. But thats not the only reason for picking them because Ireland have not lost - Yet.

I pick Scotland because their press back home have not taken to destroying the team.

If Wales were the best home nation, surely there would be slightly more 'polite' chat from their media.

If you are looking for a Worst moment, I challenge anyone to find something worse than Ben Kays 'chip over the top' against South Africa.

Worst pre-match build up comment - Brian Ashton: "I have never seen such focus in the dressing room"

Best sporting moment: The South Africans chosing not to rip Jason Robinson to shreds when he went down injured. My heart was in my mouth.

Best come back: Andy Farrell. Only a few days ago Mike Ford said he would never make it in Rugby Union, a couple of days later and he has 2 years left at the top of the English game. I wouldn't mind, but he didn't do anything in those 2 days!

  • 14.
  • At 09:30 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • Tinoflyer wrote:

Best home nation has got to be Scotland. They have not lost. But thats not the only reason for picking them because Ireland have not lost - Yet.

I pick Scotland because their press back home have not taken to destroying the team.

If Wales were the best home nation, surely there would be slightly more 'polite' chat from their media.

If you are looking for a Worst moment, I challenge anyone to find something worse than Ben Kays 'chip over the top' against South Africa.

Worst pre-match build up comment - Brian Ashton: "I have never seen such focus in the dressing room"

Best sporting moment: The South Africans chosing not to rip Jason Robinson to shreds when he went down injured. My heart was in my mouth.

Best come back: Andy Farrell. Only a few days ago Mike Ford said he would never make it in Rugby Union, a couple of days later and he has 2 years left at the top of the English game. I wouldn't mind, but he didn't do anything in those 2 days!

  • 15.
  • At 09:37 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • Ian wrote:

I agree with Jack. Wales have played Canada and the Aussies and came closer to them than England did to SA, Scotland will to the All Blacks and Ireland will to Argentina.

  • 16.
  • At 10:05 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • Tinoflyer wrote:

Best home nation has got to be Scotland. They have not lost. But thats not the only reason for picking them because Ireland have not lost - Yet.

I pick Scotland because their press back home have not taken to destroying the team.

If Wales were the best home nation, surely there would be slightly more 'polite' chat from their media.

If you are looking for a Worst moment, I challenge anyone to find something worse than Ben Kays 'chip over the top' against South Africa.

Worst pre-match build up comment - Brian Ashton: "I have never seen such focus in the dressing room"

Best sporting moment: The South Africans chosing not to rip Jason Robinson to shreds when he went down injured. My heart was in my mouth.

Best come back: Andy Farrell. Only a few days ago Mike Ford said he would never make it in Rugby Union, a couple of days later and he has 2 years left at the top of the English game. I wouldn't mind, but he didn't do anything in those 2 days!

  • 17.
  • At 10:06 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • andy wrote:

wales have played well in parts and Shanklin would be in my lions team, but as a Scotsman I can only say we have been effective against every thing put in front of us so far and look equipped to make it to the last 8 we have a reasonable line out, good backrow and a great kicker i only hope we put up a great performance against a very good AB side.

  • 18.
  • At 10:07 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • Karl wrote:

I think that the English and Irish Rugby Team might face an early exit at this world cup based on their poor performances... England did not even look like scoring a point against south africa, and Ireland, have only givin very poor performances, wkere they barely beat georgia. These two giants of rugby, is in for a big suprise when they play this weekend..

  • 19.
  • At 10:08 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • orator wrote:

Both England and Samoa were not up to the standards. But I'm sure one of these two teams is going to win the World Cup.

  • 20.
  • At 10:45 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • peter breen wrote:

Worst moment, every time Martin Corry makes one of his oh so boring impassioned speeches. The man is Englands most losing captain in modern history! the team loathe him, he never tackles, never runs with the ball and is slow. Ashton sacks him as a captain because a) he is crap and b) we lose every time he is captian and then appoints him as captain for the SA game and guess what? we are crap, more crap than normal, play like a side with no belief in our captian and get thrashed. And then he stays in the team! as captian! can anyone guess what is going to happen next? here is a clue..Corry write the most boring article about how we need to knuckle down etc etc gives a team talk in which he cries and everybody else things 'please god let this all end' and we play crap......

  • 21.
  • At 10:58 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • Spoot wrote:

Reply to #13

Couldn't agree more with you about your choice of best sporting moment. However, what we actually saw on our screens didn't prevent at least two London-based newspapers publishing reports claiming that the England forwards had to protect Robinson from further injury - complete twaddle.

  • 22.
  • At 11:08 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • Brian George wrote:

I guess four comments on Engalnd's perfomance so far:
1. Why on earth pick Andy Farrell, I mean in the SA match every ball kicked either went out of position or to directly to the Springboks!
2. Ditto Martin Corry as Captain, great in the line-out/scrum, but hardly an inspirational captain!For goodness sake bring back Dallagio as captain.
3. Hopefully Wilko and Robinson will be OK for 1/4 finals if we ever get there!
4. So what on earth has happened to the World Champions - unless of course it's all part of a master-plan - i.e, lull the comeptition into a false sense of security!

  • 23.
  • At 11:34 PM on 19 Sep 2007,
  • Basil Fawlty wrote:

How bizarre, this is not the 100M in 2012, this is the Snickers (Sorry Marathon) I think England and Ireland can only go up, and will, Wales and Scotland nobody knows (am welsh) England, may get things right by playing there rugby when it counts, at the half group stage, won 1 lost 1 and two easy teams to go, Hmmm, Wales are dependant on a miracle, Scotland could just get through to Semi's, Ireland same as Scotland, England have to perform like they can, my dad said, Good players do not become bad players over night, (Henson excluded) he's right again, (Dam him LOL) England Australia, fancy the ball up the jumper approach, England to win, AB's to beat SA in A very good final, just bet other half's Salary on it! Great touney tho

  • 24.
  • At 12:13 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Ben Morgan wrote:

You can't really compare the Scottish media to the Welsh media to say Scotland are the better team. The Scottish media don't really care too much about Rugby, in Wales on the other hand Rugby is all there is. The Media have a vastly inflated opinion of what Wales should be achieving.

The big difference between Wales and Scotland at this world cup is the quality of the coaching. I have a distinct feeling that if the coaches were reversed Wales might well have beaten Australia in Cardiff and not struggled so much against Canada. Gareth Jenkins will be gone after the tournament. It was a mistake to appoint him, he's made us look like dinosaurs in the International game. It's only when we're struggling our players take it on themselves to play to our strengths. Against Australia we gave away a daft try from that Up and under otherwise the result might have been different.

Credit to the Aussies though, they've struggled for much of the past 4 years but they can pull it together for the World Cup. I can't see them winning but they've performed much better than I expected them to

  • 25.
  • At 02:39 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • paul moore wrote:

The best thing, by far, in this world cup is that the minnows are getting bigger!
Four years ago there was not one upset and the matches between the traditional powers and weaker nations were just a waste of time.
The more money given by the irb to the developing rugby nations can only do greater good for the game internationally.
The talent, passion, skill and pride shown so far by some of the minnows has been exciting and eye-opening!
How sweet it would be if the whole world wanted to be in the rugby world cup!

  • 26.
  • At 03:11 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • fullback wrote:

I do love these public forums and the attepts at unbiased opinions...

As a Scotsman living in Australia I obviously have allegiances that put me in favour of some teams over others, but to suggest (comment 9) that Robinson or Barkley (spelling mate!) were players of the tournament is really stretching country pride!

Some great comments though along the way and agree that the home nations haven't exactly set the heather alight (or should that be onion fields?!?) but see England going through (if they perform against Tonga) Wales going through (Welsh passion and desire won't have it any other way!) Scotland going through (Italy aren't the team that they have been) and as for Ireland, I've got fears that the games against France tonight and Argentina on the 30th will be too much for the team in place at the moment...

As for the 'minnows?' You've gotta love the passion, determination, fun and even occasional skill that these guys put into the tournament playing the game they love for nothing more than the experience and pride... Remember how we used to play like that before professionalism?!?

Pick for the finals? Can't really see past the Kiwi's, but then we've said that for the last few cups as well, eh? :o)

PS Comment 19?!? What have you been drinking Orator?!?

  • 27.
  • At 07:50 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Ivan wrote:

S.A will secure a final from their side, and it doesnt look like they will meet any serious challengers along the way.

NZ will prevail from their side, but after having to beat France and Aus before facing a fresher bok team in the final.

It will be close, as it always is between these two... could go either way.

  • 28.
  • At 08:03 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • strongo wrote:

#21 that is the problem with English rugby. You cannot look to Dallagio, Wilko, Robinson, etc everytime there is a big game. It is because of this that English Rugby has stayed still for 4 years while the rest of the World (tri-naions esp) have moved on and evolved. 4 years ago England were so far ahead, but now the world has caught up and taken over. i'd like to see them play Samoa with a young(er) team, prove English rugby has a future beyond the 'old guard'.

Can england get the award for highest average age?

  • 29.
  • At 08:11 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Jez wrote:

Lets leave Andy Farrell alone shall we? To blame all England's woes on one player is frankly absurd! The truth of the matter is we have not got the players in England and all the time the RFU and clubs cannot agree on a domestic season that allows the clubs to utilise all their players whilst ensuring the national side has all its players available England will not perform at international level.
Also, for players of Andy Farrells quality (and he is quality, of that there is no doubt) to perform and break games they need space in which to work in which means forwards creating a platform going forward of quick ball. This requires forwards coming onto the ball, from deep and at pace. Just check how many times in a game Ben Kay for instance will take the ball at first receiver, stood still and then tackled behind the game line. Sort that out and things may start to go the right way!

  • 30.
  • At 08:34 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Tony wrote:

Surely Chabal's try from the half way line against Namibia has got to be try of the tournament so far. It was awesome.

We hope Ireland salvage some pride in their next two performances, and all will be forgotten if we beat (and I agree it is a big if)France on Friday night as France will then exit the tournament.

  • 31.
  • At 08:37 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Tim Sims wrote:

Can we give an award for dullest bit of self-created hype to Brian Ashton for his 'shock the world' comment? Although I suppose his team has been truly shocking, in fairness... And a positive award for Frank Hadden for not going in for any of that sort of nonsense and just getting on with the job?

Worst tackle has to be Emerick, who could easily have put Barkley in a wheelchair for life. Nieuwenhuis was stupid - especially after having been warned for a previous high shot - but not nearly as dangerous.

  • 32.
  • At 08:38 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Dave Sommerville wrote:

I agree with Paul Moore who said that the best thing about this World Cup is the emergence of the minnows. The performance of Georgia against Ireland in particular was most heartening. Even the All Blacks management said that playing Portugal was a worthwhile experience for all involved. The format for 2011 should stay at 20 teams - after all, how will Rugby Union possibly grow as a sport if we exclude people?

  • 33.
  • At 08:38 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • David wrote:

As another Scot living in Oz I thought I may as well throw my tuppence worth in ... I'm between contracts just now and therefore have watched nearly every game at a civilised time of day through the wonders of Foxtel Digital and in a lot of cases through liberal use of the fast forward facility!

Just to cement the fact I'm a rugby tragic, I've actually been to a couple of games at Ballymore (and watched others on ABC) in the current ARC - the Australian Rugby Championship for those not in the know ... which will include a number Australian rugby fans!)

Anyway half term report ... can't really see much past a NZ vs SA final, didn't think SA got into top gear against England ... then again they didn't need to ... dire performance from England in both games ... Don't remember them playing as poorly since the 80's ... However I think they will beat both the Pacific Island teams and meet Oz in QF1 ... will they improve enough to beat Oz ... possibly but even despite the indifferent Oz front row it's unlikely.

SA will probably meet Wales in QF3 ... the latter don't deserve to be there and will be packing their bags immediately after.

France / Argies / Ireland ... don't know it'll go to the wire ... great to see France lose the first game ... and deserve to and I'd love to see the Argies get to the QF ... really interesting positioning winners probably play the Scots (more later, second place play NZ ... I think Argies then France (sorry Ireland unless you really have being doing just enough, can't see 2 wins out of 2 remaining games)

Couldn't finish without saying a better Scottish performance against the "minnows" (dreadful word) than we have seen in the past ... Italy seem to be off the boil therefore for once I'll tip the Scots to make the QFs and not to lose to NZ by a truckload.

Given the above could be either Scotland or Argies in a SF against SA ... oh well never mind after that ..

All in all good tournament to date ... neither Cardiff and Edinburgh should have got games ... only real criticisms are the commentary over here which I think is a feed from ITV ... I miss Harrison / Barnes on Sky and the constant threat of citing which seems to be turning into a lottery.

Lastly good pick of the best and worst ... contenders for worst team could have been Samoa (against Tonga)or France ... other than that spot on.

  • 34.
  • At 08:55 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • David wrote:

Thanks Jez - at last someone says something sensible about Farrell.
As for the lunatic who named Farrell for worst performance for games he hasn't even played in yet...
Truth is you could pick any 15 players in England, and any coaches and any tactics - and they would STILL not be good enough.
Tim to accept that the 2003 bunch were possibly a once-in-a-generation group of players and coaches.
Please let's stop blaming individual players for the sin of not being as good as some of the greatest players to ever grace the game.

  • 35.
  • At 09:02 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • DaveM wrote:

My favourite moment so far in this world cup, was Portugal's try against New Zealand. Their unabashed joy, despite the overall score, at that score, at playing the game, playing against the ALL BLACKS, and just BEING at the world cup, restored my faith in sport. Some matches have been pretty dour, and its a shame more teams can't play with that joire de vivre that Portugal manage. Good luck to them for the future develpoment of their game, lets hope we see them back in the next WC.

  • 36.
  • At 09:53 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Ian MacK wrote:

Worst team so far: The dire Ireland, by a country mile. Finally this overhyped bunch are getting the comeuppance their arrogance deserves. I was delighted when Scotland beat them in the warm up game (great performance by Andy Henderson, a grossly underrated international centre) but that result looks less impressive when you see how close mediocre teams have been able to get to them. They choked at the last World Cup, have choked at every Six nations since, and will choke on Friday night. This Irish team are far too arrogant to carry an "underdogs" tag, the bottom line is they will be exposed for their inadequacies by France and Argentina, and perhaps the 主播大秀 will stop talking up the presence of so many "World Class" players in their side.

Being a passionate Scot I should also say that we have been unfairly tarred with the same brush as the other home nations and Ireland. We have performed clinically and soundly in our opening games, and to my mind would be capable of beating all 3 other teams on current form, and should beat Italy. I would like us to play our strongest side against the All Blacks, otherwise why bother turning up to a World Cup? However Hadden will doubtless be cute and rest some of our players, a shame but Italy appears to be the focus.

  • 37.
  • At 10:19 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • bob wrote:

England were awful and quite dispicable.

  • 38.
  • At 10:31 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Bryn Palmer wrote:

Thanks for all your comments and suggestions for new award categories -keep them coming.

Tinoflyer - Agree, if we had 'worst decision in a pressure situation', then Ben Kay would scoop it for that ridiculous attempted chip-kick against the Boks.

And Brian Ashton's "We are ready" line ahead of the same match would also be in there for the 'most deluded pre-match comment'

Tooks - was trying to remember one particular big hit, so thanks for the Sheridan on Emerick suggestion. Any others, anyone?

fief - You're right about Chris Paterson (nine out of nine kicks at goal so far), but Scotland don't just have one marksman with a 100% record. The much-maligned Dan Parks (five out of five) also shares the honours, along with Romania's Ionut Dimofte (three out of three) as the World Cup's most accurate place-kickers.

After attending last night's Italy v Portugal match at the Parc des Princes, I think Italian centre Andrea Masi takes the award for the 'worst pass of the World Cup' so far. With a three-man overlap outside him, he threw one that must have been at least three metres forward. Dire.

  • 39.
  • At 10:47 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Spencer wrote:

Best moment?

South Africans realising that a rugby great was injured and committing no one to try and win the ball from him. Nearly made me cry with pride for the game I love.

Worst moment?

In surprise at finally arriving at a breakdown first England players showing a singular lack of sense piling on top of the aforementioned rugby great. Nearly made me cry with frustration.

  • 40.
  • At 11:19 AM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • wrote:

How about and award for the the most over-used scapegoat for a very poor team? Perhaps too easy a choice in England's case.

  • 41.
  • At 12:04 PM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • mike wrote:

best bit:
portuguese players pride at their national anthem! - just shows what passion and pride in your country can do!! they even scored against the ABs!

worst bit:
gareth thomas' blatant shoulder in face of Barnes in aussie game - can anyone tell me why he has not been cited and banned for 5 games?? - was equally as bad as emerick's spear tackle!!!

  • 42.
  • At 12:39 PM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Pierre wrote:

So : 1) Chabal threw himself to the ground just for kicks . The strangling tackle from the big guy from Namibia was just a gentle caress .
2 ) Mr Rolland 's rulings are suspect just because he is the only referee who has culture and can speak French .
3 ) Let's hope France lose on Friday and are out of the tournament .
As a Brit , the visceral , narrow minded , reflex and insular francophobia of some of your correspondents makes me sick . In return , I hope all four "home nations" fail to reach the quater finals so that instead of eating frogs they can gorge themselves on humble pie . Not that this will cure their xenophobia !

  • 43.
  • At 12:45 PM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Wise old owl wrote:

Worst :- Has to be the form of the home nations. I get fed up of the southern hemisphere teams domination (2003 apart) and was really hoping that we would have at least 2 home nation teams in the mix come semi time but again it looks like NZ, AUS, SA and France for the semi places. Which is poor as coming into the competition I thought AUS were there for the beating but not the way we are all playing now.

Best :- The "smaller nations" defence, there maybe still some big scores but they are tackling there hearts out, where in previous world cups most of these big scores were down to poor tackling. Just wait to these countries start to getting there attacking qualities up to the same standard(much harder to achieve)then some of the more "established" countries may start to worry.

  • 44.
  • At 01:19 PM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • David Edwards wrote:

I agree with 36 Ireand are hugely overrated and will exit before the QFs.

  • 45.
  • At 02:11 PM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • BartonAlan wrote:

Big hits - Jason White had a good one, can't remember which Romanian suffered it, the other night, but not quite up to his hit on Gerry Flannery in last year's 6 nations! Great to see him coming back to form, I'm sure his presence has been vital in Scotland's improvement since the 6 nations this year. Pierre - go forth and support your team against Ireland, and realise that not all Brits are xenophobes. Sounds like you are also, as well as paranoid!

  • 46.
  • At 02:23 PM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Leinstered wrote:

To Ian MacK and others....

Why is that when Ireland try to ditch our underdog attitude we are considered to be arrogant by our British neighbours yet when England or Wales show the same attitude it's suddenly considered to be a "confident or winning mentality".

I have no doubt that Ireland will not be World Champions come next month but neither for that matter will Scotland, England or Wales.

Apparently Scotland played their best rugby in 10 years to beat an experimental Irish side by 1 point in a meaningless friendly - whoopy doo!!

  • 47.
  • At 03:10 PM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Ian MacK wrote:

To Leinstered,

Arrogance is good, when backed up with results. I just think some of the players in that team are living off their reputations a bit rather than form. That kind of malaise has cost England dearly, and could do Ireland. Of course Scotland do not have a prayer of winning the World Cup, but admitting as much at the group stage doesn't send out much of a positive message!

However...Scotland beat an experimental Irish side? I would be worried as a supporter about my team playing an experimental line-up two games before the World Cup, shouldn't the first team picks be all but confirmed by that stage?!

  • 48.
  • At 03:14 PM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Ian MacK wrote:

And another thing, the scoreline was 31-21, a ten point deficit... whoopee do indeed! ;-)

  • 49.
  • At 04:36 PM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • John Hartnell wrote:

And the award for the most number of jumped to conclusions goes to Pierre!

  • 50.
  • At 07:35 PM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Alex, Tunbridge Wells wrote:

Ireland are the most likely not to qualify. England may be playing just as bad, but Ireland have a much tougher group.

Scotland should qualify because once again Italy peaks the season before the RWC.

England might still get to the semi finals, especially if scrummaging is allowed against Australia.

  • 51.
  • At 08:55 PM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Welshcol wrote:

Since its half time by far the best element to me is the way the so called "underdogs" and in some cases largely amateur teams have played. The majority of the apparently mismatched games have been very entertaining with the un-favoured sides playing with pride and skill and are a credit to the game, their team and country.
An excellent example was the Italy v Portugal match last night and from a straight spectating point of view was one of the best, and not atypical in the competition so far, and was very entertaining and a credit to all concerned. A memorable competition so far and hopefully with more to come.

  • 52.
  • At 09:03 PM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • Welshcol wrote:

Since its half time, by far the BEST element to me is the way the so called "underdogs", and in some cases largely amateur teams, have played. The majority of the apparently mismatched games have been very entertaining with the un-favoured sides playing with pride and skill and are a credit to the game, their team and country.
An excellent example was the Italy v Portugal match last night and from a straight spectating point of view was one of the best, and not atypical in the competition so far, and was very entertaining and a credit to all concerned. A memorable competition so far and hopefully with more to come.

  • 53.
  • At 10:24 PM on 20 Sep 2007,
  • mwupete wrote:

JustDesserts,
Many thanks for the link to the article. A fascinating topic about which I had known absolutely nothing.

  • 54.
  • At 12:45 PM on 21 Sep 2007,
  • Warren Marabwa wrote:

i think you picked it all right, but i can see some nail biting moments and great rugby moments being created in mainly in the semi`s Habana is a pleasure to watch and i am sure we will get to see a lot from him.

  • 55.
  • At 03:12 PM on 21 Sep 2007,
  • Sam wrote:

Best AND worst... Matt Dunning's mullet

  • 56.
  • At 03:27 PM on 21 Sep 2007,
  • PetePet wrote:

I notice your column has not refered to the "best and the worst" referee decision. I know we shouldn't criticise the refs but I have to say that this is the worst world cup for referees (and I include assistants as well) missing forward passes that I can remember. One of the Wales tries against Australia was so blatently forward that their football team would have been proud of the pass. It is time to get the rule set in stone. IF A PASS IS NOT BACKWARDS THEN IT IS FORWARDS. The forth referee should be looking at these infringements as well.

The 主播大秀 is not responsible for the content of external internet sites