Ö÷²¥´óÐã

bbc.co.uk Navigation

"Bethan's a bit pi***d off."

  • Betsan Powys
  • 12 Apr 07, 12:04 PM

Not my words. That's how the Prime Minister's right hand woman introduced me to him yesterday. And she was right, I was.

When you're not allowed on the same floor as Mr Blair, let alone in the same room, when you and your camerman are kept apart to make sure you can't throw any questions his way, when you're told repeatedly that if you ask anything about the burning issue of the day - the decision to let the marines and sailors held hostage in Iran to sell their story - you'll lose your right to ask two questions about Welsh issues later in the day ... you get the picture.

In the end Mr Blair gave his one answer on the Iran story when he wanted, how he wanted. I asked some more and put it like this - before he left Milford Haven the Prime Minister was feeling a bit like I did before he walked through the door.

For those of you who read Conservative Glyn Davies' blog, you'll know what I mean when I say that I got home and wished I had a garden full of Cortadillas (right Glyn?) so I could go out and hack to my heart's content. Sadly I live in Canton in Cardiff. Not good Cortadilla country. I sort of glared at the pots instead.

Comments   Post your comment

But why were you looking to ask him questions about the marines? There are network Ö÷²¥´óÐã journalists to do that. We want you to ask him about Welsh issues...

That's all right then normal mouth, because I did. And you saw and heard his answers last night. But surely asking the Prime Minister about the big issue of the day as well is ... fair enough?

  • 3.
  • At 11:20 AM on 13 Apr 2007,
  • Matt wrote:

Betsan, I sympathise...but isn't the media fixation on (non-welsh) issues of the day (that come and go) the principle reason why the likes of Blair 'stonewall' on broader (more Welsh) issues of less transient significance? If you introduce matters of foreign policy to an election concerning the composition of the WAG it follows that a candidate's position on Iraq will be prioritised over their stance on education, health, housing or the Welsh language (great for the Lib Dems in student dominated areas etc) - there is, granted, a philosophical link - but this is a somewhat abstracted from the issues on which I as a 'normal' voter would have you challenging our senior politicians.
Cofion,
Matt.

  • 4.
  • At 12:27 PM on 13 Apr 2007,
  • Ann Gold wrote:

Sounds like Blair is as a big a liability in Wales as he is here in Scotland. A failure to expose himself to serious questioning has been a hallmark of his time in office.

Still, from the point of view of this Scottish voter it is further evidence of the need for "regime change" in our country. And it looks like Alex Salmond is on track to deliver it.

With Blair here today in Scotland "to bolster the Labour vote" we can expect a further boost to the SNP vote.

I trust my Welsh friends have cottoned on as strongly as the Scots. Mind you, at least the Welsh First Minister is not a craven boot-licker of (I'm Tory Plan B) Tony Blair MP and so might have a fiant chance of survival if he can keep him away.

Hurrah. roll on 4th May.

  • 5.
  • At 01:39 PM on 13 Apr 2007,
  • Manjit wrote:

Message 4#

'A failure to expose himself to serious questioning has been a hallmark of his time in office.'

Is that really fair? Let's just remember that Blair submits himself to a monthly press conference from regional/national/international hacks at Downing Street. He also submits himselfs to a half-hour PMQ's once a week, which means the leader of the opposition gets six questions at him (remember the old system was two 15 minute slots on Tuesdays and Thurdays). Blair also appears twice a year before all the heads of the Select Committee's where he is cross-examined on all aspects of the Governments performance, no other PM has ever done that. I think there was a statistic that showed that Blair had given more PM statements to the House of Commons than any of his immediate predecessors.

I think it's fair to say that Blair avoided doing big interviews with the big beasts of broadcasting such as Paxman and Humphrys early on his premership. But since Alastair Campbell has left Downing Street, he has appeared quite offten on the Today program and subjected himself to proper cross-examination.

Personally I think Blair subjects himself to far more scrutiny from the press than either Gordon Brown and David Cameron do. You may not like the answers he gives but that is a different matter.

"But surely asking the PM about the big issue of the day as well is...fair enough"?

Well, yes it would be...if your organisation were not already doing it - in spades. As were many other media outlets.

The PM is asked about UK issues all the time. He's hardly ever asked about Welsh issues. Let's not use what little time there is for that on other stuff, eh?

This another classic trait in the symbiotic relationship between politician and journalists, the problem is that the need to communicate yet remain adversarial has meant a breakdown, a breakdown which i think is harming our democracy. Politician wants to 'spin' and stick to script, attack-dog journo wants to catch them out on anything that doesnt actually involve policy or politics much of the time. Journalists need to realise that despite them being essentially gatekeepers between politicians and the public they are very quick to wash their hands of any fault.

If a politician communicate in a slick and professional manner, its 'spin' or lacking substance. If their communication is rough around the edges or not slick its 'amateur'...Sometimes politicians cannot win. Wales' problem is even more acute due to lack of a diverse and pluralistic media, i read the guardian as my london paper of choice and thus far i have seen one inaccurate paragraph in the 'leader' regarding the assembly elections.

We all in the political class need to ask ourselves what politics do we want in Wales, and what politics will engage people. We devolution in its infancy we have a real chance to shape our politics for the better for the people of Wales.

Anyway, rant over...

  • 8.
  • At 07:39 PM on 13 Apr 2007,
  • Luke wrote:

I know you're new to this political thing, Betsan, but you need to learn the ropes a bit. Both main channels carried a Blair clip with his Marines response - the shots were clearly pooled, something which your big Beeb bosses would have agreed to, and something which is standard practice for such events. Why would he want to spend the rest of his visit talking about it again? Are you really having a pop at the PM for having the temerity to talk about Wales and Welsh issues on a visit to… er… Wales? A bit of perspective might not go amiss.

  • 9.
  • At 09:19 PM on 13 Apr 2007,
  • glyn davies wrote:

Cortaderias Betsan - fancy name for pampas grasses. I grow about 10 different varieties.

  • 10.
  • At 12:45 AM on 17 Apr 2007,
  • Vashti wrote:

It sounds to me like Betsan is annoyed about being strongarmed regarding her choice of questions - it's one thing to say that the question has already been covered, but quite another to say that if you ask a particular question you will *not be allowed* to ask any further questions regarding Welsh issues.

Post a comment

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Comments are moderated, and will not appear on this weblog until the author has approved them.

Required
Required (not displayed)
 
    

The Ö÷²¥´óÐã is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Ö÷²¥´óÐã.co.uk